Will when times are given, he is given that have twenty four hours of your own month you to do perhaps not meets with that date as it during the genuine history. One analogy takes place in Harry Potter therefore the Prisoner regarding Azkaban whenever Sybill Trelawney means sixteen October because the Saturday, regardless of if sixteen Oct 1993 try a tuesday.
There are also contradictions inside books in this field. Such as, for the Harry Potter while the Goblet out-of Flames, each other step one Sep and you can 2 September are given due to the fact Mondays and you will, during the Harry Potter as well as the Prisoner out-of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s trial is decided into 20 April, but mindful parsing of the text message implies that it might enjoys occurred no later on than February.
Along with, inside the Harry Potter plus the Cup out-of Flames they state the Champions had been picked on the Monday 30 October, however, 30 October was a saturday into the 1994.
From inside the a bankruptcy proceeding of Quidditch From the Years, it is said your very first Quidditch Globe Cup happened in the 1473. Should your championship is actually kept the couple of years, that it conflicts on the report for the Cup from Fire your 1994 Business Cup is actually the brand new 422nd. If Quidditch Through the Many years is useful, new 422nd Quidditch Business Glass would in fact fall-in the season 3161, however if Cup from Fire is right, the first Business Cup had been held in 306.
Historical troubles [ ]
While the show, according to the schedule derived from this new Chamber out of Treasures resource, is set in the 1990s, the brand new show brightwomen.net vilkaise weblinkkiГ¤ have a tendency to looks as if it is place in the brand new late nineties to help you middle-2000s, more or less concurrent into the book of guides. For the Harry Potter and also the 1 / 2 of-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge uses a masculine pronoun to mention for the “predecessor” of your Finest Minister of the British. According to a lot more than timeline, this should take place in the summertime out of 1996, in the event the Finest Minister is John Big, whoever instantaneous ancestor was a female (is the reason basic ending up in Fudge, the ebook states the brand new election, however, Biggest wasn’t very first decided and just grabbed over just after Thatcher resigned.
It will be easy, although not impractical, one Fudge is writing about a far more faraway predecessor, due to the fact Thatcher took place of work ahead of Fudge purportedly turned into Minister to possess Secret. (Regardless if one can believe a scenario in which Fudge are delegated by Minister to have Magic to meet up to the Prime Minister while he, Fudge, was a student in a smaller sized place of work.) Additionally, brand new identity and history of the top Minister portrayed appears to a whole lot more directly suits regarding Tony Blair than out of John Biggest. A blog post on the Every single day Mail cards you to definitely Rowling is actually personal towards upcoming-Chancellor of your own Exchequer Gordon Brownish (commonly viewed as an opponent so you can Blair’s frontrunners of one’s Work Cluster, just who been successful him and you may turned into Best Minister), and therefore she might have been trying to tell you Blair’s worst front. If the guides were place in sync which have guide day away from Philosopher’s Brick, up coming it knowledge create take place in 2002 (immediately after Blair turned into Primary Minister).
Yet not, it absolutely was later reported that twenty-two November is a tuesday, which it was a student in 1994
An identical situation relates to Nicolas Flamel, who had been said as being 665 during the brand new earliest book, but Nicolas Flamel is a real historic figure and you may wouldn’t have reached you to years up until 1996, within day the first guide try wrote. The new rebuttal for it is the fact that the date the fresh “real” Nicolas Flamel came into this world cannot talk to the Nicolas Flamel off Harry Potter.
An alternate state can be found regarding Rubeus Hagrid’s tenure as the Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s meant from the series that Hagrid got one to position contained in this a couple of years out of his expulsion away from college in the 1942. In one world off Harry Potter and the Cup out of Flame, Molly Weasley reminisces in the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper apparently overlap with Molly’s age at school, it looks unlikely you to definitely she recalls an earlier gamekeeper. But not, it’s possible one to Hagrid failed to be a gamekeeper immediately once being expelled, but alternatively come as Ogg’s assistant. This is exactly probable while the when Harry thinks that he often be expelled for traveling for the broomstick as opposed to permission within his first 12 months, the guy wonders if however be allowed to remain on once the Hagrid’s secretary.